Comments on: The Firebombing of Dresden – God gives orders and we obey http://ShelleyTheRepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey Join is in our new chat forum! Sun, 05 Feb 2012 22:23:38 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v= By: mark http://ShelleyTheRepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx/comment-page-2#comment-99330569 mark Tue, 31 Jan 2012 17:52:00 +0000 http://www.shelleytherepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx#comment-99330569 there is no question in the end the germans got what they first brought, and their own woman and civilians paid for it with terrible punishment. but i can't believe how proud some of you sound. millions of russians perished, so to mention that the USA alone won against the nazis is being a little too proud. the russians in fact pushed far more stronger for germany and berlin, and the nazis were dreadfully fearful of the red army. but of course the usa liberated many parts of europe. in fact my grandfather (pole) was on a german labor field when the americans came and told him the war is over, he can go home. as far as the jew comments...the way i see it, at least from a christian point of view, the jews are no longer god's chosen people nor were at the time of the holocaust, which is obvious or else i wouldn't be able to be a christian today. anyway, no one can really judge anyone, but suffice to say that WW1 and 2 was a disgrace to humanity as a whole. there is no question in the end the germans got what they first brought, and their own woman and civilians paid for it with terrible punishment. but i can’t believe how proud some of you sound. millions of russians perished, so to mention that the USA alone won against the nazis is being a little too proud. the russians in fact pushed far more stronger for germany and berlin, and the nazis were dreadfully fearful of the red army. but of course the usa liberated many parts of europe. in fact my grandfather (pole) was on a german labor field when the americans came and told him the war is over, he can go home. as far as the jew comments…the way i see it, at least from a christian point of view, the jews are no longer god’s chosen people nor were at the time of the holocaust, which is obvious or else i wouldn’t be able to be a christian today. anyway, no one can really judge anyone, but suffice to say that WW1 and 2 was a disgrace to humanity as a whole.

]]> By: Sophie http://ShelleyTheRepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx/comment-page-2#comment-99329268 Sophie Sat, 19 Nov 2011 23:22:24 +0000 http://www.shelleytherepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx#comment-99329268 Dear Shelly, I do not mean to offend you, truly I don't. I am sickened by how someone could ever think that bombing anyone is justified. I am angry at the fact that there is so much wrong in the world, and that it was and is our fault. I am breaking inside because there is just just so much hate. I don't see how we can be at each other's throats because we believe in something different, or look different or react differently. I don't understand how humanity has come to this, to us believing that to kill innocent people is rightious and noble. That is sick. No matter how many kids, parents, families, soldiers, marines, Jews, Japanese, U.S, Canadian, Italian, and all else died in World war two because of what happened, the fire bombing of Dresden or any other city is not justifiable. Innocent people were murdered, Shelly. Imagine your home being bombed, your city destroyed and your family dead. Now imagine someone telling you that you deserved your family to die because you 'were not god's chosen person'. Not every German who fought in WWII wanted to fight, many were either told that they could fight or their family would be killed. I thought that religion was supposed to be kind, magestic and all forgiving, but it appears that those who represent their religion are just the opposite. How could you ever think that the bombing of Dresden was right? How can you not see how horid it is? What you don't seem to understand is that these were people. These were innocent people. Can you honestly say that new born babies aren't 'god's chosen people' from the start? No one can help where they are born, it just happens. You make me sick Shelly. I honestly wish that people like you could see war for what it truly is. Murder. We don't need war, it's not in our nature. People like you make me sick. I cannot believe that we as a species have fallen this low, no wonder we have war. I don't understand how anyone could believe in a all accepting god when the reality is that we're all hating on each other, picking out each other's differences and slagging them. This is why wars start. This is how it has been since the beginning of time, and if we are to change we have to do it now before we all blow each other to no return. I cannot even fathom how you actually believe that the bombing of Germany was rightious. Do you believe that the two bombs we dropped on Japan were justifiable? Do you believe that the raping of the Chinese by the Japanese soldiers was good? The fact is, is that each side did something so dreadful, so horrific and so unforgivable that we have to learn from them. We have to learn to get over our past and let go of all these hatful ways, because really, what has that given us so far? We need to get over what we did in the past, I am ashamed to be a part of the human race. Looking at some of these comments makes me want to throw up. So, dear Shelly, You are very ignorant. You have been fed very wrong things indeed, and I truly hope that you can see how aweful the things you said were. I just can't take the hate any longer. Why can't we get over ourselves and start over? Everyone makes mistakes, and it's up to us to remember them and grow from them. You're so hateful towards the Germans, even though Germany is rebuilt. The US rebuilt Germany and Japan. They sent in supplies and made sure their economy was running after the war. You're as hateful as Hitler, how can you not see that? Dear Shelly,
I do not mean to offend you, truly I don’t. I am sickened by how someone could ever think that bombing anyone is justified. I am angry at the fact that there is so much wrong in the world, and that it was and is our fault. I am breaking inside because there is just just so much hate. I don’t see how we can be at each other’s throats because we believe in something different, or look different or react differently. I don’t understand how humanity has come to this, to us believing that to kill innocent people is rightious and noble. That is sick. No matter how many kids, parents, families, soldiers, marines, Jews, Japanese, U.S, Canadian, Italian, and all else died in World war two because of what happened, the fire bombing of Dresden or any other city is not justifiable. Innocent people were murdered, Shelly. Imagine your home being bombed, your city destroyed and your family dead. Now imagine someone telling you that you deserved your family to die because you ‘were not god’s chosen person’. Not every German who fought in WWII wanted to fight, many were either told that they could fight or their family would be killed.
I thought that religion was supposed to be kind, magestic and all forgiving, but it appears that those who represent their religion are just the opposite. How could you ever think that the bombing of Dresden was right? How can you not see how horid it is? What you don’t seem to understand is that these were people. These were innocent people. Can you honestly say that new born babies aren’t ‘god’s chosen people’ from the start? No one can help where they are born, it just happens. You make me sick Shelly. I honestly wish that people like you could see war for what it truly is. Murder. We don’t need war, it’s not in our nature. People like you make me sick. I cannot believe that we as a species have fallen this low, no wonder we have war. I don’t understand how anyone could believe in a all accepting god when the reality is that we’re all hating on each other, picking out each other’s differences and slagging them. This is why wars start. This is how it has been since the beginning of time, and if we are to change we have to do it now before we all blow each other to no return. I cannot even fathom how you actually believe that the bombing of Germany was rightious. Do you believe that the two bombs we dropped on Japan were justifiable? Do you believe that the raping of the Chinese by the Japanese soldiers was good? The fact is, is that each side did something so dreadful, so horrific and so unforgivable that we have to learn from them. We have to learn to get over our past and let go of all these hatful ways, because really, what has that given us so far? We need to get over what we did in the past, I am ashamed to be a part of the human race. Looking at some of these comments makes me want to throw up.
So,
dear Shelly,
You are very ignorant. You have been fed very wrong things indeed, and I truly hope that you can see how aweful the things you said were. I just
can’t
take
the hate
any
longer.
Why can’t we get over ourselves and start over? Everyone makes mistakes, and it’s up to us to remember them and grow from them.
You’re so hateful towards the Germans, even though Germany is rebuilt. The US rebuilt Germany and Japan. They sent in supplies and made sure their economy was running after the war. You’re as hateful as Hitler, how can you not see that?

]]> By: Steph http://ShelleyTheRepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx/comment-page-2#comment-99324688 Steph Fri, 22 Jul 2011 00:11:50 +0000 http://www.shelleytherepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx#comment-99324688 Shelley Goodman, YOU ARE DEVIL IN PERSON!! Shelley Goodman, YOU ARE DEVIL IN PERSON!!

]]> By: linda http://ShelleyTheRepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx/comment-page-2#comment-99324556 linda Wed, 13 Jul 2011 12:50:45 +0000 http://www.shelleytherepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx#comment-99324556 Shelley you are a sick minded piece of shit, Hahaha you are just proving with your statements that Christians and Jews are evil racist pricks you Jesus loving whore suck Jesus dich you ugly American bitch. Why r u so obsessed with Germans, did a German guy used you cheap American pussy for sex or Wtf is wrong with you Shelley you are a sick minded piece of shit, Hahaha you are just proving with your statements that Christians and Jews are evil racist pricks you Jesus loving whore suck Jesus dich you ugly American bitch. Why r u so obsessed with Germans, did a German guy used you cheap American pussy for sex or Wtf is wrong with you

]]> By: Bruno53 http://ShelleyTheRepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx/comment-page-2#comment-99323938 Bruno53 Sat, 28 May 2011 22:31:11 +0000 http://www.shelleytherepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx#comment-99323938 Me hating Germans? I admire the Germany that produced a Johann Sebastian Bach and a Ludwig van Beethoven. Germany gave us great composers of classical music [Mozart was Austrian BUT he is just also a part of the cultural greatness of Germany]. But I don't admire the Germany that gave us Hitler, Nazis and Buchenwald. Too bad this same Germany went berserk in wars and genocides. The only way to stop it was firebombing it. I regret my words. But I can't see it in any other way. If Germany never again creates future wars and genocides, then I can say those Allies' airmen and the German's civilians that were killed in these air firebombings did not die in vain. Case closed, and permanently. Me hating Germans? I admire the Germany that produced a Johann Sebastian Bach and a Ludwig van Beethoven. Germany gave us great composers of classical music [Mozart was Austrian BUT he is just also a part of the cultural greatness of Germany]. But I don’t admire the Germany that gave us Hitler, Nazis and Buchenwald. Too bad this same Germany went berserk in wars and genocides. The only way to stop it was firebombing it. I regret my words. But I can’t see it in any other way. If Germany never again creates future wars and genocides, then I can say those Allies’ airmen and the German’s civilians that were killed in these air firebombings did not die in vain. Case closed, and permanently.

]]> By: Haze http://ShelleyTheRepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx/comment-page-2#comment-99323456 Haze Sun, 24 Apr 2011 18:56:23 +0000 http://www.shelleytherepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx#comment-99323456 Mrs. Goodman, you worthless anti-German zionist bitch!!! You arrogant racist Jews are the worst people on earth, because of you god chosen bastards Hitler came to power as you exploited Germany by the Treaty of Versailles! For you other blind and brainwashed yankees who got no skills about European history: Get to know something to know about your American citizen Benjamin Freedman, the ex-Zionist... and listen to his speech in 1961, to know why it all happened. --> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQapkVCx1HI (9 parts) Mrs. Goodman, you worthless anti-German zionist bitch!!!
You arrogant racist Jews are the worst people on earth, because of you god chosen bastards Hitler came to power as you exploited Germany by the Treaty of Versailles!
For you other blind and brainwashed yankees who got no skills about European history:

Get to know something to know about your American citizen Benjamin Freedman, the ex-Zionist… and listen to his speech in 1961, to know why it all happened.

–> http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQapkVCx1HI

(9 parts)

]]> By: mb http://ShelleyTheRepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx/comment-page-2#comment-99323414 mb Thu, 21 Apr 2011 03:55:20 +0000 http://www.shelleytherepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx#comment-99323414 Are you kidding me? You think killing 30,000 people is Gods will? I'm pretty sure that according to the Christian faith killing is not allowed at all? right? Lets just go around and kill everyone who committed wrong deeds.... (sarcasm) You sound really educated in your own faith Shelley..... (sarcasm) Are you kidding me? You think killing 30,000 people is Gods will? I’m pretty sure that according to the Christian faith killing is not allowed at all? right?
Lets just go around and kill everyone who committed wrong deeds…. (sarcasm)
You sound really educated in your own faith Shelley….. (sarcasm)

]]> By: Bruno53 http://ShelleyTheRepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx/comment-page-2#comment-99323174 Bruno53 Wed, 06 Apr 2011 17:50:21 +0000 http://www.shelleytherepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx#comment-99323174 I stand on my words. Even admitting Allies went too far firebombing Nazi Germany, I am sorry to regret many German citizens that your ancestors, who supported Adolf Hitler and his Nazi gang of killers, deserved too much the be blame for this tragedy besides Roosevelt, Churchill and RAF Field Marshall Arthur "Bomber" Harris, the "brain" behind the massive firebombing of Hitler's Germany. They supported Hitler and his war crimes, and the Allies were "glad" to bomb the hell out of them as a punishment. Case closed. I stand on my words. Even admitting Allies went too far firebombing Nazi Germany, I am sorry to regret many German citizens that your ancestors, who supported Adolf Hitler and his Nazi gang of killers, deserved too much the be blame for this tragedy besides Roosevelt, Churchill and RAF Field Marshall Arthur “Bomber” Harris, the “brain” behind the massive firebombing of Hitler’s Germany. They supported Hitler and his war crimes, and the Allies were “glad” to bomb the hell out of them as a punishment. Case closed.

]]> By: Wolfgang http://ShelleyTheRepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx/comment-page-2#comment-99321625 Wolfgang Tue, 15 Feb 2011 16:44:41 +0000 http://www.shelleytherepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx#comment-99321625 I am not forgetting anything and of course the Allies effort to stop Nazi Germany was the best that could have happened. You do not need to tell me about history my friend after the war we were taught it do an extent that any form of Nazism has been completely deleted from our minds and we live in permanent guilt because we were raised so. You seem to have misunderstood was I was saying. I did not mean that the firebombings of Dresden and such were not justified but what I originally planned to emphasize was the tastelees and extremely offensive remarks of our friend shelleytherepublican towards such a sensitive topic. So my mothers brother who died in the Firebombings with the age of 5 got what he deserved, and is to blame for the Nazi-crimes? Thats basically the notion that Shelley is promoting through this blog which is plain disgusting, ignorant and illogical. Opinions just like that were responsible for the Nazis taking over in the first place, simple fascist mindset, unfortunately people like Shelley fail to understand this and continue spreading their hatred. I am not forgetting anything and of course the Allies effort to stop Nazi Germany was the best that could have happened. You do not need to tell me about history my friend after the war we were taught it do an extent that any form of Nazism has been completely deleted from our minds and we live in permanent guilt because we were raised so. You seem to have misunderstood was I was saying. I did not mean that the firebombings of Dresden and such were not justified but what I originally planned to emphasize was the tastelees and extremely offensive remarks of our friend shelleytherepublican towards such a sensitive topic.
So my mothers brother who died in the Firebombings with the age of 5 got what he deserved, and is to blame for the Nazi-crimes? Thats basically the notion that Shelley is promoting through this blog which is plain disgusting, ignorant and illogical.
Opinions just like that were responsible for the Nazis taking over in the first place, simple fascist mindset, unfortunately people like Shelley fail to understand this and continue spreading their hatred.

]]> By: Bruno53 http://ShelleyTheRepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx/comment-page-2#comment-99321571 Bruno53 Sat, 12 Feb 2011 23:00:09 +0000 http://www.shelleytherepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx#comment-99321571 Seem to forget some here that it was Adolf Hitler who started this war. And he cursed the German civilians who were firebombed by the Allies. How come Herr Wolfgang boy can't see it that way? And I am quite critical of today USA's foreign policies by the way, Wolfgang. And I am a US citizen who reads world history. Seem to forget some here that it was Adolf Hitler who started this war. And he cursed the German civilians who were firebombed by the Allies. How come Herr Wolfgang boy can’t see it that way? And I am quite critical of today USA’s foreign policies by the way, Wolfgang. And I am a US citizen who reads world history.

]]> By: Bruno53 http://ShelleyTheRepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx/comment-page-2#comment-99321569 Bruno53 Sat, 12 Feb 2011 22:54:45 +0000 http://www.shelleytherepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx#comment-99321569 Well, it is true the Nazi Germans got what they deserved. But aren't now some in the USA MAKING the same mistakes the Nazi Germans did decades ago? As George Santayana once said, "those who don't remember the past are condemned to repeat it". Much to think about. Something tells me USA someday will have another "Dresden" sooner or later. Wish I won't be around when it happens. And Herr Wolfgang boy should not forget the mistakes his country did. Of course I can understand him. Well, it is true the Nazi Germans got what they deserved. But aren’t now some in the USA MAKING the same mistakes the Nazi Germans did decades ago? As George Santayana once said, “those who don’t remember the past are condemned to repeat it”. Much to think about. Something tells me USA someday will have another “Dresden” sooner or later. Wish I won’t be around when it happens. And Herr Wolfgang boy should not forget the mistakes his country did. Of course I can understand him.

]]> By: Wolfgang http://ShelleyTheRepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx/comment-page-2#comment-99318162 Wolfgang Wed, 24 Nov 2010 23:15:24 +0000 http://www.shelleytherepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx#comment-99318162 Up until now I believed you were either trying to be satirical with this or simply being the most ignorant person that has ever walked the earth but at some point there is a crossing line to bad taste even in satire (even though by now I think you remarks here are dead serious) and you have clearly crossed it. You basically spat my ancestors right in the face who suffered death an pain during those firebombings. War is always dirty but insulting innocent war victims is plain disgusting. You are a worthless piece of scum and this is no insult but justified fact. You are a fascist, ignorant, purely evil and satanic monstrosity. A disgrace to all that is good and by claiming to be christian also an insult to God, Jesus and everything they stand for. I wish for you the worst possible life, the worst of circumstances that might change your view. Or better may you be erased from the face of the earth by divine intervention so that it can be a better place with less hate and ignorance, and I know that I am sinning here but I don't care for I can never be as bad a person as you. May you rot in hell. sincerely Up until now I believed you were either trying to be satirical with this or simply being the most ignorant person that has ever walked the earth but at some point there is a crossing line to bad taste even in satire (even though by now I think you remarks here are dead serious) and you have clearly crossed it.
You basically spat my ancestors right in the face who suffered death an pain during those firebombings. War is always dirty but insulting innocent war victims is plain disgusting.
You are a worthless piece of scum and this is no insult but justified fact.
You are a fascist, ignorant, purely evil and satanic monstrosity.
A disgrace to all that is good and by claiming to be christian also an insult to God, Jesus and everything they stand for.
I wish for you the worst possible life, the worst of circumstances that might change your view.
Or better may you be erased from the face of the earth by divine intervention so that it can be a better place with less hate and ignorance, and I know that I am sinning here but I don’t care for I can never be as bad a person as you.
May you rot in hell.

sincerely

]]> By: Maximilian Bauer http://ShelleyTheRepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx/comment-page-2#comment-99314201 Maximilian Bauer Sat, 05 Jun 2010 12:05:44 +0000 http://www.shelleytherepublican.com/2007/04/20/the-firebombing-of-dresden-god-gives-orders-and-we-obey.aspx#comment-99314201 Bastard! I'm German. My grandpa was child soldier in army those days and it was hell for everybody! Jews but also the German citizens who can't do shit for this war! It's always that way: fucked up are those, who aren't really involved. For killing Hitler you guys also were too stupid. And I remember a whole lot of other stupid wars in the name of USA. :) I would watch you guys and your uncle Sammy. Vietnam, ... Iraq, ... Abu Gharib. ;D Where people are kicked to death and look like they got hit by a bus. That's nice!! Bastard! I’m German. My grandpa was child soldier in army those days and it was hell for everybody! Jews but also the German citizens who can’t do shit for this war! It’s always that way: fucked up are those, who aren’t really involved. For killing Hitler you guys also were too stupid. And I remember a whole lot of other stupid wars in the name of USA. :) I would watch you guys and your uncle Sammy. Vietnam, … Iraq, … Abu Gharib. ;D Where people are kicked to death and look like they got hit by a bus. That’s nice!!

]]>